Lanterns Is Not Canceled. It Is Not Renewed Either.

Lanterns has not been canceled. It has not been renewed for a second season either. As of the morning of November 11, we found no announcement from HBO in either direction.

The cancellation talk started with one sentence in a Variety report, and that sentence does not say the show is canceled.

What Variety reported

On November 10, Variety published a report on why James Gunn and Peter Safran are out at the top of DC Studios. One passage covers Lanterns. As the story reads now, it says the show "had strong viewership and averaged 19 million viewers globally per episode going into the finale. Yet an insider at the company suggests the crime drama isn't quite capturing the zeitgeist, pointing out the show has yet to be renewed for a second season."

Variety does not name the insider. The story does not say HBO has made a decision.

The wording appears to have changed after publication. ComicBook.com quoted the passage on the night of November 10 as saying the show "didn't get renewed for a second season," and later noted that Variety had updated it. Variety's page shows it was last modified on the morning of November 11. We only read the current version.

A day earlier, a separate Variety piece on the future of DC's characters put it this way: "a Season 2 renewal hasn't been announced."

On social media, the line spread as a cancellation.

What the show's writers said

Chris Cantwell, whom Comic Book Club identifies as a co-showrunner on the series, answered on Bluesky on the night of November 10. He wrote that he had not heard anything. About two hours later he added: "Nothing's cancelled. Calm down."

Chris Mundy, the show's co-creator and co-showrunner, spoke at a Lanterns awards event in Westwood, California on Monday, November 9, the day the leadership change was announced. The Playlist asked him whether the shakeup could help Season 2 move forward sooner.

"We thought everything had settled [after the merger]," Mundy said. "I can imagine a world where everyone retreats to their corners, but then, you know, it's a coin flip, 50/50."

The numbers

The audience was there. Deadline reported on October 8 that the season finale, which debuted on October 4, drew 10.5 million global viewers in its first three days. That was a series best and 13% above the premiere. The season was averaging 19.3 million global viewers, which Deadline said kept it among the top five HBO series launches in the platform's history.

Deadline wrote then that a Season 2 renewal was pending.

On October 14, Variety reported that Safran told Collider news on a second season should arrive "before the end of the year." He tied it to the writers' room. "If we're able to come up with what we believe to be a worthy successor to a beloved and great first season, that's what's going to dictate whether there's a second season," Safran said.

What changed at DC Studios

On November 9, Variety reported that Gunn and Safran were out as co-chairmen of DC Studios. Jeremy Latcham, a Marvel Studios veteran, replaces them as president and chief creative officer. Variety's November 10 report describes the two as dismissed.

Safran is the executive who gave the end of the year timeline.

What is still set

Aaron Pierre will play John Stewart again in Man of Tomorrow, the Superman sequel Gunn wrote and directed. Variety reports the film is due next summer and wrapped in late August.

We will update this when HBO or DC Studios announces a decision.

Talk about it with us in the CXM Discord.